内嵌纤维增强复合材料加固砌体结构研究进展

景杰婧; 周长东

doi:10.11835/j.issn.2096-6717.2021.127

您当前的位置：

首页 >

文章列表页 >

内嵌纤维增强复合材料加固砌体结构研究进展

土木工程 | 更新时间：2023-06-25

- 内嵌纤维增强复合材料加固砌体结构研究进展
- Research progress on masonry structures strengthened with near-surface mounted fiber reinforced polymer
- 土木与环境工程学报 2023年45卷第1期页码：209-224
- 作者机构：
  
  北京交通大学土木建筑工程学院，北京 100044
- 作者简介：
  
  景杰婧（1995- ），女，博士生，主要从事工程结构加固技术研究，E-mail：19115024@bjtu.edu.cn。
  周长东（通信作者），男，教授，博士生导师，E-mail：zhouchangdong@163.com。
- 基金信息：
  
  国家自然科学基金(52078030;51678039)
- DOI：10.11835/j.issn.2096-6717.2021.127
  中图分类号： TU365;TU599
- 收稿：2020-12-29，
  
  纸质出版：2023-02-25
- 稿件说明：
移动端阅览
景杰婧, 周长东. 内嵌纤维增强复合材料加固砌体结构研究进展[J]. 土木与环境工程学报, 2023,45(1):209-224.

JING Jiejing, ZHOU Changdong. Research progress on masonry structures strengthened with near-surface mounted fiber reinforced polymer[J]. Journal of Civil and Environmental Engineering, 2023, 45(1): 209-224.
景杰婧, 周长东. 内嵌纤维增强复合材料加固砌体结构研究进展[J]. 土木与环境工程学报, 2023,45(1):209-224. DOI： 10.11835/j.issn.2096-6717.2021.127.

JING Jiejing, ZHOU Changdong. Research progress on masonry structures strengthened with near-surface mounted fiber reinforced polymer[J]. Journal of Civil and Environmental Engineering, 2023, 45(1): 209-224. DOI： 10.11835/j.issn.2096-6717.2021.127.

摘要

砖石作为建筑材料在世界范围内广泛使用，由砖石和砂浆组成的砌体结构抗拉、抗剪强度较低，抗震性能不足，地震作用下容易破坏甚至倒塌，需进行补强加固

以改善砌体结构的力学性能。由于抗拉强度高、重量轻、安装方便和耐腐蚀等优势，纤维增强复合材料（Fiber Reinforced Polymer，简称FRP）在砌体结构加固领域具有广阔的应用前景；由于对结构的重量和外观影响很小，在历史砌体建筑加固中，内嵌FRP（Near-Surface Mounted FRP，简称NSM-FRP）加固法更有优势。总结学者们对NSM-FRP加固砌体结构的相关研究进展，并对其未来发展进行展望。

Abstract

Brick and stone are widely used as building material in the world. Masonry structure composed of brick

stone and mortar has low tensile and shear strength

insufficient seismic resistance

and is prone to damage or even collapse under earthquake action. Therefore

strengthening is needed to improve the mechanical properties of masonry structure. Due to high tensile strength

light weight

easy installation and corrosion resistance

fiber reinforced polymer(FRP) has been widely used to strengthen the masonry structure. Near-surface mounted FRP(NSM-FRP) has more advantages in strengthening historic masonry buildings because it has little influence on the weight and appearance of the structures. In this paper

the research progress of masonry structures strengthened with NSM-FRP is summarized

and the development of masonry structures strengthened with NSM-FRP is prospected.

关键词

Keywords

references

潘毅 , , 陈建 , , 包韵雷 , , 等 . . 长宁6.0级地震村镇建筑震害调查与分析 [J]. . 建筑结构学报 , , 2020 , , 41 (( Sup1 ): ): 297 -- 306 ..

Y PAN , , J CHEN , , Y L BAO , , et al . . Seismic damage investigation and analysis of rural buildings in M S 6.0 Changning earthquake [J]. . Journal of Building Structures , , 2020 , , 41 (( Sup1 ): ): 297 -- 306 . . (in Chinese) .

杨玉成 , , 杨柳 , , 高云学 , , 等 . . 唐山地震多层砖房震害与强度的关系 [J]. . 地震工程与工程振动 , , 1981 , , 1 (( 1 ): ): 21 -- 33 ..

Y C YANG , , L YANG , , Y X GAO , , et al . . Relation between damage to multistory brick buildings and their strength during the Tangshan earthquake [J]. . Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration , , 1981 , , 1 (( 1 ): ): 21 -- 33 . . (in Chinese) .

王威 , , 周颖 , , 梁兴文 , , 等 . . 砌体结构在2008汶川大地震中的震害经验 [J]. . 地震工程与工程振动 , , 2010 , , 30 (( 1 ): ): 60 -- 68 ..

W WANG , , Y ZHOU , , X W LIANG , , et al . . Lessons learnt from masonry structural damage in 2008 Wenchuan earthquake [J]. . Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration , , 2010 , , 30 (( 1 ): ): 60 -- 68 . . (in Chinese) .

谢启芳 , , 薛建阳 , , 赵鸿铁 . . 汶川地震中古建筑的震害调查与启示 [J]. . 建筑结构学报 , , 2010 , , 31 (( Sup2 ): ): 18 -- 23 ..

Q F XIE , , J Y XUE , , H T ZHAO . . Seismic damage investigation and analysis of ancient buildings in Wenchuan earthquake [J]. . Journal of Building Structures , , 2010 , , 31 (( Sup2 ): ): 18 -- 23 . . (in Chinese) .

蔡晓光 , , 孙有为 , , 郭晓云 . . 芦山地震建筑震害统计分析 [J]. . 自然灾害学报 , , 2015 , , 24 (( 6 ): ): 112 -- 119 ..

X G CAI , , Y W SUN , , X Y GUO . . Statistical analysis of building damage in M s 7.0 Lushan earthquake [J]. . Journal of Natural Disasters , , 2015 , , 24 (( 6 ): ): 112 -- 119 . . (in Chinese) .

J INGHAM , , M GRIFFITH . . Performance of unreinforced masonry buildings during the 2010 darfield (Christchurch, NZ) earthquake [J]. . Australian Journal of Structural Engineering , , 2010 , , 11 (( 3 ): ): 207 -- 224 ..

C L WANG , , V SARHOSIS , , N NIKITAS . . Strengthening/retrofitting techniques on unreinforced masonry structure/element subjected to seismic loads: A literature review [J]. . The Open Construction and Building Technology Journal , , 2018 , , 12 (( 1 ): ): 251 -- 268 ..

尹世平 , , 成帅安 , , 荆磊 . . FRP和TRC加固砌体墙受剪性能试验研究 [J]. . 建筑结构学报 , , 2020 , , 41 (( Sup1 ): ): 315 -- 322 ..

S P YIN , , S A CHENG , , L JING . . Experimental research on shear performance of masonry wall strengthened with FRP and TRC [J]. . Journal of Building Structures , , 2020 , , 41 (( Sup1 ): ): 315 -- 322 . . (in Chinese) .

陶毅 , , 古金本 , , 信任 , , 等 . . CFRP网格修复后多层砌体结构墙体的抗震性能 [J]. . 西南交通大学学报 , , 2019 , , 54 (( 6 ): ): 1258 -- 1267 ..

Y TAO , , J B GU , , R XIN , , et al . . Seismic performance of multi-storey masonry wall repaired by carbon fiber reinforced polymer grids [J]. . Journal of Southwest Jiaotong University , , 2019 , , 54 (( 6 ): ): 1258 -- 1267 . . (in Chinese) .

陈良 , , 袁建力 . . 微弯曲碳纤维板加固古砖塔模型试验研究 [J]. . 建筑结构学报 , , 2019 , , 40 (( 11 ): ): 64 -- 72 ..

L CHEN , , J L YUAN . . Experimental study of ancient brick pagoda strengthened with light bended CFRP plate [J]. . Journal of Building Structures , , 2019 , , 40 (( 11 ): ): 64 -- 72 . . (in Chinese) .

S A BABATUNDE . . Review of strengthening techniques for masonry using fiber reinforced polymers [J]. . Composite Structures , , 2017 , , 161 : 246 -- 255 ..

A PARGHI , , M S ALAM . . A review on the application of sprayed-FRP composites for strengthening of concrete and masonry structures in the construction sector [J]. . Composite Structures , , 2018 , , 187 : 518 -- 534 ..

P ZAMPIERI , , N SIMONCELLO , , C D TETOUGUENI , , et al . . A review of methods for strengthening of masonry arches with composite materials [J]. . Engineering Structures , , 2018 , , 171 : 154 -- 169 ..

J VACULIK , , P VISINTIN , , N G BURTON , , et al . . State-of-the-art review and future research directions for FRP-to-masonry bond research: Test methods and techniques for extraction of bond-slip behaviour [J]. . Construction and Building Materials , , 2018 , , 183 : 325 -- 345 ..

J A O BARROS , , D R S M FERREIRA , , A S FORTES , , et al . . Assessing the effectiveness of embedding CFRP laminates in the near surface for structural strengthening [J]. . Construction and Building Materials , , 2006 , , 20 (( 7 ): ): 478 -- 491 ..

R SERACINO , , N M JONES , , M S ALI , , et al . . Bond strength of near-surface mounted FRP strip-to-concrete joints [J]. . Journal of Composites for Construction , , 2007 , , 11 (( 4 ): ): 401 -- 409 ..

L DE LORENZIS , , J G TENG . . Near-surface mounted FRP reinforcement: An emerging technique for strengthening structures [J]. . Composites Part B: Engineering , , 2007 , , 38 (( 2 ): ): 119 -- 143 ..

R B PETERSEN , , M J MASIA , , R SERACINO . . In-plane shear behavior of masonry panels strengthened with NSM CFRP strips. I: Experimental investigation [J]. . Journal of Composites for Construction , , 2010 , , 14 (( 6 ): ): 754 -- 763 ..

H MALJAEE , , B GHIASSI , , P B LOURENÇO . . Bond behavior in NSM-strengthened masonry [J]. . Engineering Structures , , 2018 , , 166 : 302 -- 313 ..

R B PETERSEN , , M J MASIA , , R SERACINO . . Bond behavior of near-surface mounted FRP strips bonded to modern clay brick masonry prisms: Influence of strip orientation and compression perpendicular to the strip [J]. . Journal of Composites for Construction , , 2009 , , 13 (( 3 ): ): 169 -- 178 ..

C R WILLIS , , Q YANG , , R SERACINO , , et al . . Bond behaviour of FRP-to-clay brick masonry joints [J]. . Engineering Structures , , 2009 , , 31 (( 11 ): ): 2580 -- 2587 ..

J KASHYAP , , C R WILLIS , , M C GRIFFITH , , et al . . Debonding resistance of FRP-to-clay brick masonry joints [J]. . Engineering Structures , , 2012 , , 41 : 186 -- 198 ..

D DIZHUR , , M C GRIFFITH , , J M INGHAM . . Pullout strength of NSM CFRP strips bonded to vintage clay brick masonry [J]. . Engineering Structures , , 2014 , , 69 : 25 -- 36 ..

P Y YU , , P SILVA , , A NANNI . . Bond behavior of near-surface mounted FRP bars to masonry [J]. . Journal of Composites for Construction , , 2018 , , 22 (( 4 ): ): 04018024 ..

郭子雄 , , 刘宝成 , , 刘阳 . . 石材表层嵌埋CFRP筋粘结性能试验研究 [J]. . 工程力学 , , 2011 , , 28 (( 7 ): ): 59 -- 64 ..

Z X GUO , , B C LIU , , Y LIU . . Experimental study on bond behavior between nsm CFRP rods and stone for composite stone beams [J]. . Engineering Mechanics , , 2011 , , 28 (( 7 ): ): 59 -- 64 . . (in Chinese) .

R SERACINO , , M R RAIZAL SAIFULNAZ , , D J OEHLERS . . Generic debonding resistance of EB and NSM plate-to-concrete joints [J]. . Journal of Composites for Construction , , 2007 , , 11 (( 1 ): ): 62 -- 70 ..

R LUMANTARNA , , D T BIGGS , , J M INGHAM . . Compressive, flexural bond, and shear bond strengths of in situ New Zealand unreinforced clay brick masonry constructed using lime mortar between the 1880s and 1940s [J]. . Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering , , 2014 , , 26 (( 4 ): ): 559 -- 566 ..

S S ZHANG , , J G TENG , , T YU . . Bond strength model for CFRP strips near-surface mounted to concrete [J]. . Journal of Composites for Construction , , 2014 , , 18 (( 3 ):): A4014003 ..

Ö S TÜRKMEN , , S N M WIJTE , , J VACULIK , , et al . . High-speed pullout behavior of deep-mounted CFRP strips bonded with a flexible adhesive to clay brick masonry [J]. . Structures , , 2020 , , 28 : 1153 -- 1172 ..

J VACULIK , , P VISINTIN , , W LUCAS , , et al . . Durability of near-surface-mounted FRP-to-clay brick masonry retrofits under environmental exposure [J]. . Journal of Composites for Construction , , 2020 , , 24 (( 1 ): ): 04019058 ..

施楚贤 . . 砌体结构 [M]. , 4版 . 北京 : : 中国建筑工业出版社 , , 2017 : : 17 ..

C X SHI . . Masonry Structure [M]., 4th Edition . Beijing : : China Architecture & Building Press , , 2017 : : 17 . (in Chinese) .

M R VALLUZZI , , L BINDA , , C MODENA . . Mechanical behaviour of historic masonry structures strengthened by bed joints structural repointing [J]. . Construction and Building Materials , , 2005 , , 19 (( 1 ): ): 63 -- 73 ..

魏智辉 , , 潘毅 , , 邱洪兴 , , 等 . . 勾缝加固砖砌体墙的抗压性能试验 [J]. . 哈尔滨工业大学学报 , , 2017 , , 49 (( 12 ): ): 184 -- 188 ..

Z H WEI , , Y PAN , , H X QIU , , et al . . Experimental study on compressive behavior of masonry walls strengthened with pointing mortar [J]. . Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology , , 2017 , , 49 (( 12 ): ): 184 -- 188 . . (in Chinese) .

J WITZANY , , R ZIGLER , , K KROFTOVÁ . . Strengthening of compressed brick masonry walls with carbon composites [J]. . Construction and Building Materials , , 2016 , , 112 : 1066 -- 1079 ..

砌体基本力学性能试验方法标准 : GB/T 50129—2011 [S].. 北京 : : 中国建筑工业出版社， , 2011 ..

Standard for test methods for basic mechanical properties of masonry : GB/T 50129-2011 [S]. . Beijing : : China Architecture and Building Press , , 2011 . . (in Chinese) .

Standard test method for diagonal tension (shear) in masonry assemblages : ASTM E519/E519M-20 [S]. . USA : : ASTM International , , 2020 ..

T C RILEM 76, -LUM . . Diagonal tensile strength tests of small wall specimens [M]//. RILEM Technical Recommendations for the testing and use of construction material , , London, UK : : CRC Press , , 1994 ..

李保亮 , , 丁百湛 , , 朱强强 . . CFRP嵌入式加固砌体结构抗剪性能试验研究 [J]. . 砖瓦世界 , , 2014 (. ( 7 ): ): 33 -- 35 ..

B L LI , , B Z DING , , Q Q ZHU . . Experimental study on shear performance of masonry structure reinforced with CFRP embedded [J]. . Brick & Tile World , , 2014 (. ( 7 ): ): 33 -- 35 . . (in Chinese) .

V TURCO , , S SECONDIN , , A MORBIN , , et al . . Flexural and shear strengthening of un-reinforced masonry with FRP bars [J]. . Composites Science and Technology , , 2006 , , 66 (( 2 ): ): 289 -- 296 ..

H MAHMOOD , , J M INGHAM . . Diagonal compression testing of FRP-retrofitted unreinforced clay brick masonry wallettes [J]. . Journal of Composites for Construction , , 2011 , , 15 (( 5 ): ): 810 -- 820 ..

D DIZHUR , , M GRIFFITH , , J INGHAM . . In-plane shear improvement of unreinforced masonry wall panels using NSM CFRP strips [J]. . Journal of Composites for Construction , , 2013 , , 17 (( 6 ): ): 04013010 ..

A JAFARI , , A V OSKOUEI , , M BAZLI , , et al . . Effect of the FRP sheet's arrays and NSM FRP bars on in-plane behavior of URM walls [J]. . Journal of Building Engineering , , 2018 , , 20 : 679 -- 695 ..

T LI , , N GALATI , , J G TUMIALAN , , et al . . Analysis of unreinforced masonry concrete walls strengthened with glass fiber-reinforced polymer bars [J]. . ACI Structural Journal , , 2005 , , 102 (( 4 ): ): 569 -- 577 ..

S CASACCI , , C GENTILINI , , A DI TOMMASO , , et al . . Shear strengthening of masonry wallettes resorting to structural repointing and FRCM composites [J]. . Construction and Building Materials , , 2019 , , 206 : 19 -- 34 ..

P Y YU , , P SILVA , , A NANNI . . In-plane performance of unreinforced concrete masonry strengthened with prestressed GFRP bars [J]. . Journal of Composites for Construction , , 2017 , , 21 (( 1 ): ): 04016064 ..

M TOMAZEVIC . . Earthquake-resistant design of masonry buildings [M]. , London : : Imperial College Press , , 1999 : : 109 -- 150 ..

刘廷滨 . . 水平嵌筋加固砖砌体墙粘结机理及抗震性能研究 [D]. . 兰州 : : 兰州交通大学 , , 2016 ..

T B LIU . . Research on bonding mechanism and seismic performance of horizontal reinforced brick masonry wall [D]. . Lanzhou : : Lanzhou Jiaotong University , , 2016 . . (in Chinese) .

潘磊 , , 刘廷滨 , , 裴先科 , , 等 . . 水平嵌筋加固砖砌体墙抗震性能试验研究 [J]. . 世界地震工程 , , 2019 , , 35 (( 2 ): ): 157 -- 164 ..

L PAN , , T B LIU , , X K PEI , , et al . . Experimental study on seismic performance of brick walls strengthened with embedded horizontal steel bars [J]. . World Earthquake Engineering , , 2019 , , 35 (( 2 ): ): 157 -- 164 . . (in Chinese) .

张广泰 , , 侍克斌 , , 李元吉 . . 后植筋加固砖墙体抗震性能试验研究 [J]. . 建筑结构学报 , , 2013 , , 34 (( 5 ): ): 145 -- 150 ..

G T ZHANG , , K B SHI , , Y J LI . . Experimental study on seismic behavior of brick walls strengthened with embedded bars [J]. . Journal of Building Structures , , 2013 , , 34 (( 5 ): ): 145 -- 150 . . (in Chinese) .

孟凡龙 , , 赵建昌 . . 嵌筋墙体抗剪破坏机理分析 [J]. . 河南城建学院学报 , , 2011 , , 20 (( 2 ): ): 19 -- 22 ..

F L MENG , , J C ZHAO . . Analysis on shear failure mechanism of embedded bars reinforced wall [J]. . Journal of Henan University of Urban Construction , , 2011 , , 20 (( 2 ): ): 19 -- 22 . . (in Chinese) .

H MIRABI BANADAKI , , R MORSHED , , A ESLAMI . . In-plane cyclic performance of adobe walls retrofitted with near-surface-mounted steel rebars [J]. . Engineering Structures , , 2019 , , 194 : 106 -- 119 ..

R SOTI , , A R BARBOSA . . Experimental and applied element modeling of masonry walls retrofitted with near surface mounted (NSM) reinforcing steel bars [J]. . Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering , , 2019 , , 17 (( 7 ): ): 4081 -- 4114 ..

郭子雄 , , 柴振岭 , , 胡奕东 , , 等 . . 嵌缝加固条石砌筑石墙抗震性能试验研究 [J]. . 土木工程学报 , , 2010 , , 43 (( Sup1 ): ): 136 -- 141 ..

Z X GUO , , Z L CHAI , , Y D HU , , et al . . Study on seismic behavior of stone walls strengthened by mounting bars in bed joints [J]. . China Civil Engineering Journal , , 2010 , , 43 (( Sup1 ): ): 136 -- 141 . . (in Chinese) .

刘小娟 . . 钢筋—聚合物砂浆嵌缝加固石墙抗震性能试验研究 [D]. . 福建泉州 : : 华侨大学 , , 2011 ..

X J LIU . . Experimental study on sesmic behavior of stone masonry walls strengthened by mounting bars in bed joints [D]. . Quanzhou, Fujian : : Huaqiao University , , 2011 . . (in Chinese) .

胡奕东 , , 郭子雄 , , 柴振岭 , , 等 . . 嵌缝加固条石砌筑石墙的抗震性能初探 [J]. . 工程抗震与加固改造 , , 2009 , , 31 (( 6 ): ): 24 -- 27,41 ..

Y D HU , , Z X GUO , , Z L CHAI , , et al . . Study on seismic behavior of stone wall strengthened by mounting bards in bed joints [J]. . Earthquake Resistant Engineering and Retrofitting , , 2009 , , 31 (( 6 ): ): 24 -- 27,41 . . (in Chinese) .

K M C KONTHESINGHA , , M J MASIA , , R B PETERSEN , , et al . . Experimental evaluation of static cyclic in-plane shear behavior of unreinforced masonry walls strengthened with NSM FRP strips [J]. . Journal of Composites for Construction , , 2015 , , 19 (( 3 ): ): 04014055 ..

K M C KONTHESINGHA , , M J MASIA , , R B PETERSEN , , et al . . Static cyclic in-plane shear response of damaged masonry walls retrofitted with NSM FRP strips - An experimental evaluation [J]. . Engineering Structures , , 2013 , , 50 : 126 -- 136 ..

T LI , , N GALATI , , G TUMIALAN , , et al . . FRP strengthening of URM walls with openings - experimental results [J]. . The Masonry Society Journal , , 2005 , , 23 (( 1 ): ): 47 -- 57 ..

周长东 , , 张腾 , , 景杰婧 . . 碳纤维板嵌缝加固砖墙抗震性能试验研究 [J]. . 建筑结构学报 , , 2020 , , 41 (( Sup1 ): ): 323 -- 330 ..

C D ZHOU , , T ZHANG , , J J JING . . Experimental study on seismic performance of brick wall strengthened with seam embedded CFRP plates [J]. . Journal of Building Structures , , 2020 , , 41 (( Sup1 ): ): 323 -- 330 . . (in Chinese) .

砌体结构设计规范 : GB 50003—2011 [S]. . 北京 : : 中国建筑工业出版社 , , 2011 ..

Code for design of masonry structures : GB 50003-2011 [S]. . Beijing : : China Architecture and Building Press , , 2011 . . ( in Chinese) .

施楚贤 , , 周海兵 . . 配筋砌体剪力墙的抗震性能 [J]. . 建筑结构学报 , , 1997 , , 18 (( 6 ): ): 32 -- 40 ..

C X SHI , , H B ZHOU . . Research on seismic behavior of reinforced masonry shear walls [J]. . Journal of Building Structures , , 1997 , , 18 (( 6 ): ): 32 -- 40 . . (in Chinese) .

朱伯龙 , , 陈玲俐 . . 水平配筋砌块墙抗剪机理分析与实验验证 [J]. . 四川建筑科学研究 , , 1998 , , 24 (( 3 ): ): 5 -- 9 ..

B L ZHU , , L L CHEN . . Analysis of the strengthening mechanism of brick masonry with horizontal reinforcement [J]. . Building Science Research of Sichuan , , 1998 , , 24 (( 3 ): ): 5 -- 9 . . (in Chinese) .

周炳章 , , 夏敬谦 . . 水平配筋砖砌体抗震性能的试验研究 [J]. . 建筑结构学报 , , 1991 , , 12 (( 4 ): ): 31 -- 43 ..

B Z ZHOU , , J Q XIA . . Experimental study on seismic behaviour of brick masonry with horizontal reinforcement [J]. . Journal of Building Structures , , 1991 , , 12 (( 4 ): ): 31 -- 43 . . (in Chinese) .

C R WILLIS , , R SERACINO , , M C GRIFFITH . . Out-of-plane strength of brick masonry retrofitted with horizontal NSM CFRP strips [J]. . Engineering Structures , , 2010 , , 32 (( 2 ): ): 547 -- 555 ..

M C GRIFFITH , , J KASHYAP , , ALI M S MOHAMED . . Flexural displacement response of NSM FRP retrofitted masonry walls [J]. . Construction and Building Materials , , 2013 , , 49 : 1032 -- 1040 ..

D DIZHUR , , M GRIFFITH , , J INGHAM . . Out-of-plane strengthening of unreinforced masonry walls using near surface mounted fibre reinforced polymer strips [J]. . Engineering Structures , , 2014 , , 59 : 330 -- 343 ..

N GALATI , , G TUMIALAN , , A NANNI . . Strengthening with FRP bars of URM walls subject to out-of-plane loads [J]. . Construction and Building Materials , , 2006 , , 20 (( 1/2 ): ): 101 -- 110 ..

Ö S TÜRKMEN , , S N M WIJTE , , B T DE VRIES , , et al . . Out-of-plane behavior of clay brick masonry walls retrofitted with flexible deep mounted CFRP strips [J]. . Engineering Structures , , 2021 , , 228 : 111448 ..

李保亮 , , 丁百湛 , , 黄国君 , , 等 . . CFRP嵌入式加固砌体结构抗弯性能试验研究 [J]. . 新型建筑材料 , , 2014 , , 41 (( 9 ): ): 91 -- 94 ..

B L LI , , B Z DING , , G J HUANG , , et al . . Experimental study of out-of-plane flexural performance of masonry structures strengthened with near-surface mounted carbon fiber reinforced polymer [J]. . New Building Materials , , 2014 , , 41 (( 9 ): ): 91 -- 94 . . (in Chinese) .

刘阳 , , 郭子雄 , , 刘宝成 , , 等 . . 嵌埋CFRP筋组合石梁受弯性能试验研究 [J]. . 建筑结构学报 , , 2011 , , 32 (( 3 ): ): 75 -- 81 ..

Y LIU , , Z X GUO , , B C LIU , , et al . . Experimental study on flexural behavior of NSM CFRP-stone composite beams [J]. . Journal of Building Structures , , 2011 , , 32 (( 3 ): ): 75 -- 81 . . (in Chinese) .

浏览量

下载量

CSCD

文章被引用时，请邮件提醒。

提交

工具集

关联资源

双肢砌体墙的抗震性能与水平承载力计算模型

砌体墙转动变形现象及其对抗震性能的影响研究综述